Search
Close this search box.

Green certified offices more defensive in pandemic property market

MSCI South Africa Green Annual Property Index celebrates five years, highlighting impressive cumulative results.

Now in its fifth year, the MSCI South Africa Green Annual Property Index continues to support the investment case for Green Buildings in the commercial property sector.

Released annually in conjunction with the Green Building Council of South Africa (GBCSA) and sponsored by Growthpoint Properties, the index provides an independent, globally consistent view on the investment performance of green-certified and non-certified offices.

At the end of 2020, the index sample comprised 289 prime and A grade office properties valued at R54.5 billion, of which 139 were green-certified buildings. These were compared to 150 non-certified offices of a similar quality.

“Growthpoint is proud to sponsor the MSCI Green Property Index for Offices for the fifth year. Its insights have never been more relevant than in today’s market. The index’s findings continue to strongly support the case for investing in green-certified buildings. The MSCI Green Property Index for Offices demonstrates the real rewards of investing in green certified buildings and provides proof that these buildings are better placed to retain and attract tenants, and are cheaper to operate. As the owner of the biggest portfolio of green-certified office buildings in Africa, this puts Growthpoint in a strong position for the future. We remain committed to providing workspaces that positively impact business and the environment, as well as the physical and mental well-being of the people who occupy them,” says Paul Kollenberg, Growthpoint’s Head of Asset Management: Office.

Green certified offices outperformed in 2020, continuing long-term trend

For the year ended December 2020, the green-certified office sample delivered a total return of -1.6%, 170bps above the non-certified sample’s return of -3.1%. Capital growth was the main driver of outperformance as the green-certified sample held its value better in a challenging operating environment for the office market.

Over the index’s five-year history, the sample of green-certified offices delivered an annualised outperformance of 260bps as its compound annual total return of 7.3% exceeded the 4.7% of non-certified P & A-grade offices.

On a cumulative basis, this equates to a total return of 42.1% as it outperformed the non-certified sample by 13.2%.

Green-certified office assets deemed lower risk through crisis

As the COVID-19 pandemic stressed property fundamentals, green-certified offices proved more defensive, both from an income and capital perspective as its superior capital growth was the result of a better net income growth and lower discount rate.

Amid the impact of COVID-19, the green-certified office sample saw a significantly smaller decline in net operating income when compared to non-certified offices. (-5.8% vs. -10.1%) and had a 40bp lower discount rate when compared to the non-certified sample, implying that its future cashflows were deemed lower risk.

Also telling was a lower vacancy rate of 12.7% versus the non-green sample of 14.9%, highlighting the value occupiers are attaching to green certified premises.

The meaning behind these results

Released by MSCI in April 2021, the index results reinforced the association between quality and green-certified buildings, as reflected by a 31% higher capital value per square metre, more resilient capital growth and a higher net operating income per square meter compared to the non-certified office buildings.

“It is wonderful to see that after five years of tracking green-certified buildings, we can see real evidence showing that they provide higher returns to the investor because they have been more defensive through the economic downturn and the COVID crisis. Primary metrics like higher net income and lower vacancy point directly to desirability of these buildings by tenants. This has translated into better capital growth over the last five years.” says Eileen Andrew, Vice President, MSCI.

Georgina Smit, GBCSA Head of Technical echoes this sentiment, adding that the results also emphasise the positive role that certified buildings can play within the broader responsible investing context. “For investors, these results indicate that certified green buildings are attractive investment options as well as ensuring future climate resilience and delivering on mitigation interventions associated with green building design and operation.”

GBCSA will host a webinar on Friday 28 May to give deeper insight into the latest MSCI South Africa Annual Green Property Index 2020 results. GBCSA’s Georgina Smit will be in discussion with MSCI South Africa Vice President for Client Coverage, Eileen Andrew; Gareth Allison, MSCI Executive Director and Head of Client Coverage for Sub-Saharan Africa; and Head of Sustainability and Utilities at Growthpoint Properties, Grahame Cruickshanks. Click here for more information.

In a nutshell:

Comparison of Green Star Certified Buildings vs Non-Certified Buildings in 2020

  Certified Non-certified
Total Return -1.6% -3.1%
Vacancy 12.7% 14.9%
Net operating income -5.8% -10.1%
Capital value per square metre 21 216.9/m2 16 117.1/m2

 

Individual Membership

Designed for professionals acting in their individual capacity, including single consultant-businesses.

Organisational Membership

Ideal for companies, government departments, and organisations.

  • Total Employees: 1 - 5 Employees - R 4080.00
  • Total Employees: 6 - 20 Employees - R 12570.00
  • Total Employees: 21 - 50 Employees - R 24690.00
  • Total Employees: 51 Plus Employees - R 43840.00

Lisa Reynolds

Chief Executive Officer & Executive Director

Lisa Reynolds is the CEO of the Green Building Council South Africa.

Lisa was the driver for the drafting of Energy Efficiency Standards and Regulations for Buildings and has been involved in Energy Efficiency since 2003. She serves on many committees in the SABS and within the energy management professionals’ space. She was President of the SAEEC from 2016 to 2019 and was the previous President of the ESCo (Energy Services Companies) Association. Lisa was instrumental in the formation of SAFEE (Southern African Females in Energy Efficiency) within SAEEC.

She has assisted the South African Government with its Green Building Framework policies, Energy Efficiency Tax Incentives and Energy Efficiency Strategies

Her passion for the “Green space” started with the birth of the Green Building Council in 2007. Lisa served on the Board and the Technical Committee of the GBCSA, as well as on several Technical Working Groups for Rating Tools and Criteria. Lisa. became CEO in June 2020.

Lisa has a BSc, an MBA and a CEM. Lisa’s awards include the 2007 ETA Award for Women, 2008 Individual Energy (SAEE), 2012 SABS Standards Writer Award; the 2014 Women in Energy (SAWIEN); and the 2016 Ian Lane Hall of Fame award.

Lisa is committed to growing the Green Economy within a Green Recovery.

Organisational categories

As an organisational member, you will fall into one of the below categories, and be charged according to specific size indicators. Please reach out to us for any further clarity on which category is best for your organisation

Property Developers

Annual Turnover

Investors, Owners, Property Managers

Total Asset Value

Major Corporate Tenants & Retail

Annual Gross Rentals

Building Contractors

Annual Turnover

Building Product Manufacturers & Distributors

Annual Turnover

Professional Services: Architects, Designers, Engineers, Quantity Surveyors, PM’s, Consultants, Legal

Number of employees

Research, Higher Education, NGO’S & Regulators

NGO or Research/Higher Education/ Regulators

Related Interests: Utilities, Financial, Insurance, etc.

Annual Turnover

Government

Local/ municipal/ provincial/ state 
Contact GBCSA to confirm your category